Memberships Made for Serious Collectors

At My Own Private Nostalgia, our monthly trading card membership is more than just a subscription — it’s a celebration of your passion. Each month, members receive one or more hand-selected, random trading cards that spark memories and ignite that nostalgic thrill. As a member, you’ll also enjoy exclusive discounts from Freedom Card Grading Services, giving your entire collection the care it deserves. We treat every card with the utmost respect, honoring the stories and personal value behind each one. Join a community that values preservation, passion, and the pure joy of collecting.
Three FCGS-graded collectible cards in clear slabs: a 1991 Upper Deck Michael Jordan All-Star card, a 2017 DC Comics Injustice Doomsday holfoil card, and a 2020 Decision Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez portrait card, all graded GEM MT 10.

Because Every Card Deserves Respect

Freedom Card Grading Services provides a quality solution for your trading card grading needs. Veteran-owned and operated, we offer affordable prices and the FASTEST turnaround times in the industry.

Professional Grading That Speaks for Itself

  • Precision grading – Easy submission! Get them back in just 10 days with our premium service!!!
  • Flat grading fee per card…absolutely NO fine print, price-gouging fees for high value, memorabilia, or autographed cards as charged by “mainstream” graders.
  • High quality labels that won’t slip or fade.
  • We grade all types of trading cards up to 3.5” x 5” in size and up to 180pt thick.
  • Veteran-owned & operated.
  • Autograph authentication services currently NOT available, but COMING SOON!!!
LEARN MORE

Your Trusted Source for Professionally Graded Cards

Choose the tier and categories that work best for you. You can choose from three different categories: including Baseball, Basketball and Football. Once your category is selected, choose your tier to receive a monthly graded trading card(s).

membership tiers and categories

basic

  • One Graded Card at current $29.99 market value or higher.
  • Discounted Grading Services provided by Freedom Card Grading Services.
  • Earn voucher for two free graded cards after minimum purchase of five graded cards.

ultimate

  • Three Graded Cards at current or combined $49.99 market value or higher.
  • Discounted Grading Services provided by Freedom Card Grading Services.
  • Earn voucher for two free graded cards after minimum purchase of five graded cards.

premium

  • Five Graded Cards at current or combined $99.99 market value or higher.
  • Discounted Grading Services provided by Freedom Card Grading Services.
  • Earn voucher for four free graded cards after minimum purchase of five graded cards.

membership categories

Baseball

Our extensive baseball card collection, featuring everything from legendary vintage finds to today’s rising stars. Whether you're looking for rare rookie cards, autographed memorabilia, or exclusive limited releases, our selection offers top-quality items that cater to every type of baseball fan and serious collector.

Basketball

Our basketball category offers a diverse selection of graded trading cards, ranging from rookie cards and limited editions to autographed memorabilia and vintage gems. Whether you're a collector or looking to invest, we provide high-quality, sought-after cards from top players and iconic moments in basketball history.

Football

Our football category features a wide range of graded trading cards, including rookie cards, autographed collectibles, and limited-edition sets. From iconic legends to rising stars, our collection offers something for every fan and collector, making it the perfect place to start building or enhance your football card portfolio.

Pokémon

COMING SOON !!!

Magic The Gathering

COMING SOON !!!

Collector Questions, Expert Answers

Have questions? You're in the right place. Here you'll find answers to some of the most common questions about our services, turnaround times, membership options, and more.

Each month, you'll receive a professionally graded trading card from our friends at Freedom Card Grading Services — included in the tier you choose, whether it be baseball, basketball or football. We curate each card from both current stars and iconic legends from various teams to appeal to all levels of collectors and enthusiasts.

Yes! All cards in your subscription are professionally graded by our trusted third-party grading company, Freedom Card Grading Services. We ensure every card you receive is authenticated and encapsulated, so you know exactly what you're getting in terms of quality and value.

While our subscription offers tiers for only baseball, basketball and football currently, we are working on growing our brand to include various other sports like hockey, soccer or possibly even professional wrestling to name a few. We also look forward to adding tiers for Pokémon and Magic The Gathering soon. Stay tuned for those options!

As a subscriber, you get exclusive discounts on all grading services provided by Freedom Card Grading Services. Whether it’s vintage treasures or modern pulls, we treat your cards with the utmost respect and care, ensuring they're returned to you preserved, protected, and professionally graded!
A lineup of seven collectible trading cards featuring characters and athletes including Charizard, Olivia Dunne, Nolan Ryan, Reggie Jackson, Roger Staubach, and Travis Hunter, displayed in a variety of vibrant holographic and vintage styles.

Elevate Your Collection with Professionally Graded Cards

shop now

JOIN THE INNER CIRCLE OF NOSTALGIA

Join our My Own Private Nostalgia mailing list and stay connected with us! Keeping updated on all things connected to our store or subscription service. This service is provided by collectors, for collectors.
Large group illustration of Marvel superheroes and villains, featuring characters like Spider-Man, Wolverine, Hulk, Captain America, Iron Man, and the Fantastic Four, all standing together in dynamic comic-book style on a transparent background.
Black and white logo for My Own Private Nostalgia featuring a superhero-style character reading comics, surrounded by vintage pop culture icons like a Game Boy, action figure, and cassette tape.